
I'm a fat dude. I'm on my way to being a non-fat dude, but I am what I am at the moment.
In order to make the transition from orb to rail, I've had to do some homework. I had to research things about diet, exercise, nutrition and (very importantly, I think) the psychology underlying weight loss.
During that research, I've been pretty ethnographic. I joined the official "I'm not ashamed to admit I'm a tubby-wubby (at least online) club" and learned that the bulk of the other heavyweights duking it out with excess fat rolls happen not to share my status as a male.
Women are more "into" the pound-dropping thing than are men. There are some very obvious explanations for that. Some are societal. Others may have a foundation that lies a bit deeper.
We fat dudes can do all right for ourselves despite protruding bellies. Other guys aren't particularly judgmental and women, for whatever reason, are generally cool with guys who are wrapped with a little extra bacon. Even if they'd prefer a thinner, healthier dude they seem willing, by and large, to look past a guy's tendency to order that second Reuben sandwich or to eat a full bag of Doritos in one setting.
Meanwhile, guys are prone to judging women by their size. Fat girls just aren't hot to most guys. Chubby-chasers are a distinct minority and even those men who are incredibly socially aware have an inner voice telling them that, all other things being equal, the skinnier girl is hotter.
Hey, I tend to have a wider perspective than most guys and even I don't think fat chicks are sexy. Most guys snicker a little inside when they see "BBW".
Is that wrong? Absolutely. Appearance and character are completely unrelated. Inner and exterior beauty do not go hand-in-hand. What Naomi Wolf termed the "Beauty Myth" has undoubtedly destroyed millions of lives. It's cruel, wrong, hurtful, demeaning, objectifying, phallocentric and more than a tiny bit evil.
Men should judge women by the content of their characters and not by the size of their underpants. Some of us try really, really hard to do that, too.
And although I am breaking a left-wing, progressive taboo (because, surprise, surprise, I am generally one of those enlightened souls who actually read bell hooks, Susan Faludi, Rianne Eisler, Dworkin, Mackinnon, et al. and finds himself nodding his head in agreement frequently), I'm going to give it to you straight. I'm also a balls-out heterosexist hypocrite.
You don't have to be rail-thin for me to think you're attractive. If you're fat, however, you don't look good to me.
Screw me? Fine. Here's the bigger secret. All of those other guys agree with me. One some level. Even the most enlightened. Even the leftiest, granola-chewing, pony-tailed, Birkenstock dude secretly lusts more for the "conventionally attractive" than he does for the chubster. There are exceptions--outlying chubby-chasers, etc.--but they're rare. If, as a woman, you think you've found an exception... Well, you've PROBABLY found a liar.
Look, I know it's not fair and that it stinks to high heavens, but it's true. My background isn't particularly buttoned-down and corporate. I've lived with women getting advanced degrees in Women Studies from far-left schools. I've spent countless hours with the most feminist of feminists. I've hung with the LGBT community. Protest marchers, enlightened souls, Take Back the Night, "Straight not narrow", damn the patriarchy to hell, etc., etc., etc.
I count among my friends the most liberated and enlightened folks around when it comes to gender biases and our society's tendencies. But guess what? If you get a few organic micro-brews into the guys, they'll 'fess up.
All things being equal, they dig the conventionally attractive women.
That's unfair and it puts extra pressure on bigger women. But, it's true.
In a poll of 1,000,000 heterosexual men, we could ask a simple question...
All other things being equal, would you prefer company, friendship and/or sexual involvement with Woman A or Woman B?
A.

B.

If you think "A" is going to get more than a 2% approval rating from a representative group of 1,000,000 men... Well, you're delusional.
The Beauty Myth is the Beauty Truth.
Most of it is probably a socialization thing. Some of it may be a hard-wired thing. Either way, it's the real deal.
To the attractive goes the attention. And the opportunity. And all the rest. You walk a much more difficult road as a fat woman.
I'm lucky to be a guy in that regard. Being a fat dude hasn't been all that hard. No one really cares all that much. Being a fat woman, on the other hand, would be a massive pain in the ass.
So, although this post may have seemed (on some level) to be an assault on the BBW community, it isn't. It's an acknowledgment. The big women who are trying to drop pounds are working toward their goals in an extremely pressurized and intense environment.
I wish them all the best and want them to know how impressed I am with their efforts.
The progressive human being in me wants all of them with an interest in losing weight to do it for the right reasons--health, a feeling of wellness, etc. The bastard male in me can't wait to see an increase in the hottie population.
Am I a hypocrite? Am I trying to have it both ways? Yes. Consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds and I'm okay with the dialectic, you know?
This concludes my crazed rant. Good luck, ladies.